I just got mine in. It was out of the box a whole 20 or 30 min. It's back
in the box and I'm seeing if I can return it.
First, the resolution sucks. Only 512 steps for steering, and 256 steps for
the pedals. For analog pots, that's really bad I think. The cheap black
momo has twice that in the steering.
Secondly, the pedals are WAY too high. I have 11.5" size feet and I have to
operate the pedals with my TOES! If I actually put my feet up on the
pedals, my heels are 2" off the base (which is a bit small).
The wheel feels well built, but on the track I'm all over the place. On
long straights without input it just goes back and forth all over the track.
There is a 2-3 deg area of slop in the wheel. You can move the wheel back
and forth with no acknowledgement of the input. You can clearly see this on
the Axis screen in the drivers.
It's not dead spot. There is NO dead spot adjustment.
The clamping system is not secure at all, especially if your desk is rounded
on the edge. It's better than the DFP (at least it don't fall off when you
let go), but it's weak and spongy, and the wheel rotates downward as you are
driving. It also moves all over the place.
I'm really disappointed in this. I had high hopes :(
FWIW...
-Larry
I'm happy with mine
--
Steve H
"Larry" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:5Phog.43578$fG3.6019@dukeread09...
>I just got mine in. It was out of the box a whole 20 or 30 min. It's
>back.....................
How do i check the resolution of the pots?
I have mounted a 4cm thick wooden plate on top of the pedal base, that
way i have achieved the correct height. And i get my feet closer to seat
height.
The problem with weaving on longer straights must be down to car setup ?
Or the slop you mention. No slop in mine.
I had high hopes too, and for most things the wheel are pretty much ok.
Martin.
"Larry" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:5Phog.43578$fG3.6019@dukeread09...
Quoted text (32 lines)
>I just got mine in. It was out of the box a whole 20 or 30 min. It's back >in the box and I'm seeing if I can return it. > > First, the resolution sucks. Only 512 steps for steering, and 256 steps > for the pedals. For analog pots, that's really bad I think. The cheap > black momo has twice that in the steering. > > Secondly, the pedals are WAY too high. I have 11.5" size feet and I have > to operate the pedals with my TOES! If I actually put my feet up on the > pedals, my heels are 2" off the base (which is a bit small). > > The wheel feels well built, but on the track I'm all over the place. On > long straights without input it just goes back and forth all over the > track. > > There is a 2-3 deg area of slop in the wheel. You can move the wheel back > and forth with no acknowledgement of the input. You can clearly see this > on the Axis screen in the drivers. > > It's not dead spot. There is NO dead spot adjustment. > > The clamping system is not secure at all, especially if your desk is > rounded on the edge. It's better than the DFP (at least it don't fall off > when you let go), but it's weak and spongy, and the wheel rotates downward > as you are driving. It also moves all over the place. > > I'm really disappointed in this. I had high hopes :( > > FWIW... > > -Larry >Btw, im using thrustmaster driver 1.FFD.2006/2.2.1.1
"Marni" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:44a25aab$0$193$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (12 lines)
> > How do i check the resolution of the pots? > > I have mounted a 4cm thick wooden plate on top of the pedal base, that > way i have achieved the correct height. And i get my feet closer to seat > height. > > The problem with weaving on longer straights must be down to car setup ? > Or the slop you mention. No slop in mine. > > I had high hopes too, and for most things the wheel are pretty much ok. >You don't have problems with drift on the track?
If you are in the TM control panel, and you move the wheel slightly left to
right, you are not seeing a 2-3 deg deadzone in the wheel before it
responds?
-Larry
"straiton" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:1151462355.762440@teuthos...
Quoted text (11 lines)
> I'm happy with mine > -- > > Steve H > > "Larry" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:5Phog.43578$fG3.6019@dukeread09... >>I just got mine in. It was out of the box a whole 20 or 30 min. It's >>back..................... > >So am I.
-Larry
]
"Marni" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:44a26474$0$176$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (18 lines)
> Btw, im using thrustmaster driver 1.FFD.2006/2.2.1.1 > > > "Marni" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:44a25aab$0$193$[email hidden]... >> >> How do i check the resolution of the pots? >> >> I have mounted a 4cm thick wooden plate on top of the pedal base, that >> way i have achieved the correct height. And i get my feet closer to seat >> height. >> >> The problem with weaving on longer straights must be down to car setup ? >> Or the slop you mention. No slop in mine. >> >> I had high hopes too, and for most things the wheel are pretty much ok. >> >
> You don't have problems with drift on the track?
No
> If you are in the TM control panel, and you move the wheel slightly left
> to right, you are not seeing a 2-3 deg deadzone in the wheel before it
> responds?
In the control panel, yes, i suppose there's a little, but i don't notice
anything in games
--
Steve H
No
In the control panel, yes, i suppose there's a little, but i don't notice
anything in games
--
Steve H
Thanks for being the guinea pig pig on this Larr... However it would
seemingly Cemement the thoughts about Thrust-crappers since the t2 days.
They are crap, I could never make their products work right, and for hmmm 12
itmes I have bought of theirs back in the days, they were shit. Once I got
a different wheel, I was so pissed even though relieved, as I was like "as
god as my whitness, I will never deal with spiking pots again." Ha Ha.
I know damn well hundreds of people had same experience and moved to ecci or
TSW, or like me budget priced MS. Thousands of posts (through 90's) can
prove it. Now If I could mod this MS wheel, the only thing I would change
is a way to put a nicer wheel on it's chassis.
So, It would seem, that TM is like trailer trash, you just cant get the
trash out even if they move up town (IE the wheel looks better).
Larry enlightened us with:
Quoted text (23 lines)
> So am I. > > -Larry > ] > "Marni" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:44a26474$0$176$[email hidden]... >> Btw, im using thrustmaster driver 1.FFD.2006/2.2.1.1 >> >> >> "Marni" <[email hidden]> wrote in message >> news:44a25aab$0$193$[email hidden]... >>> >>> How do i check the resolution of the pots? >>> >>> I have mounted a 4cm thick wooden plate on top of the pedal base, >>> that way i have achieved the correct height. And i get my feet >>> closer to seat height. >>> >>> The problem with weaving on longer straights must be down to car >>> setup ? Or the slop you mention. No slop in mine. >>> >>> I had high hopes too, and for most things the wheel are pretty much >>> ok.I actually had pretty good luck with the old TM's (TM2's). They were built
like tanks. Pots did go bad, but that can be expected.
I love the MS wheels. Unfortunaltey after years and years of service mine
finally died, as as you know MS discontinued them.
The software was never really right either, and never got updated. Not
once.
A new MS wheel like the old one with 10 bit resolution would be great :)
I'm leaning towards getting a TSW2 Cup. I wish the new Logitech was
shipping now as I'd give that a try instead, but that thing is more months
away than I think my Momo is going to last.
To clarify, I do NOT think the Thrustmaster Rallye GT is built like crap.
It's actually quite stout. It just doesn't perform for me and I can't drive
it.
-Larry
"PlowBoy" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:dr9pg.11402$f76.7166@dukeread06...
Quoted text (44 lines)
> Thanks for being the guinea pig pig on this Larr... However it would > seemingly Cemement the thoughts about Thrust-crappers since the t2 days. > They are crap, I could never make their products work right, and for hmmm > 12 itmes I have bought of theirs back in the days, they were shit. Once I > got a different wheel, I was so pissed even though relieved, as I was like > "as god as my whitness, I will never deal with spiking pots again." Ha > Ha. > > I know damn well hundreds of people had same experience and moved to ecci > or TSW, or like me budget priced MS. Thousands of posts (through 90's) > can prove it. Now If I could mod this MS wheel, the only thing I would > change is a way to put a nicer wheel on it's chassis. > > So, It would seem, that TM is like trailer trash, you just cant get the > trash out even if they move up town (IE the wheel looks better). > > > > Larry enlightened us with: >> So am I. >> >> -Larry >> ] >> "Marni" <[email hidden]> wrote in message >> news:44a26474$0$176$[email hidden]... >>> Btw, im using thrustmaster driver 1.FFD.2006/2.2.1.1 >>> >>> >>> "Marni" <[email hidden]> wrote in message >>> news:44a25aab$0$193$[email hidden]... >>>> >>>> How do i check the resolution of the pots? >>>> >>>> I have mounted a 4cm thick wooden plate on top of the pedal base, >>>> that way i have achieved the correct height. And i get my feet >>>> closer to seat height. >>>> >>>> The problem with weaving on longer straights must be down to car >>>> setup ? Or the slop you mention. No slop in mine. >>>> >>>> I had high hopes too, and for most things the wheel are pretty much >>>> ok. > >
Larry wrote:
> I just got mine in. It was out of the box a whole 20 or 30 min. It's back
> in the box and I'm seeing if I can return it.
>
> First, the resolution sucks. Only 512 steps for steering, and 256 steps for
> the pedals. For analog pots, that's really bad I think. The cheap black
> momo has twice that in the steering.[snip]
Don't these companies know who they're selling to? Sounds like the way
Act-Labs screwed the later versions of the Force RS (4096 res down to
256).
Glad my early Force RS is still going strong.
Kendt
On Fri, 30 Jun 2006 11:54:12 -0400, Larry wrote:
I recently "upgraded" my wheel from a non-ff TSW2 to a Momo DFP, keeping
the TSW pedals as they're much better than the flimsy plastic ones that
come with the Momo. I couldn't be happier with the setup. I had
originially bought the DFP as a backup wheel so I could race while
converting my TSW over to USB using a plasma lite board, but I got
hooked on the excellent FF the DFP provides.
Maybe you should consider that route, too. $80 on a DFP isn't too much,
and as the wheel is playstation compatible, you should have no trouble
selling it at a minor loss if you discover you don't like it.
cheers, uwe
--
GPG Fingerprint: 2E 13 20 22 9A 3F 63 7F 67 6F E9 B1 A8 36 A4 61
Quoted text (15 lines)
> I actually had pretty good luck with the old TM's (TM2's). They were built > like tanks. Pots did go bad, but that can be expected. > > I love the MS wheels. Unfortunaltey after years and years of service mine > finally died, as as you know MS discontinued them. > > The software was never really right either, and never got updated. Not > once. > > A new MS wheel like the old one with 10 bit resolution would be great :) > > I'm leaning towards getting a TSW2 Cup. I wish the new Logitech was > shipping now as I'd give that a try instead, but that thing is more months > away than I think my Momo is going to last. >I can't use a DFP. They blew the clamp design and if you have a
rounded-edge desk it won't stay in place.
Why they shipped that without the center clamp is beyond my comprehension.
I tried one. Took it back the same night.
I clamped it to the desk tightly, turned around to move the box out of the
way, and it literally fell right off the desk onto the floor all by itself.
-Larry
"Uwe Sch�rkamp" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (35 lines)
> On Fri, 30 Jun 2006 11:54:12 -0400, Larry wrote: >> I actually had pretty good luck with the old TM's (TM2's). They were >> built >> like tanks. Pots did go bad, but that can be expected. >> >> I love the MS wheels. Unfortunaltey after years and years of service >> mine >> finally died, as as you know MS discontinued them. >> >> The software was never really right either, and never got updated. Not >> once. >> >> A new MS wheel like the old one with 10 bit resolution would be great :) >> >> I'm leaning towards getting a TSW2 Cup. I wish the new Logitech was >> shipping now as I'd give that a try instead, but that thing is more >> months >> away than I think my Momo is going to last. >> > > I recently "upgraded" my wheel from a non-ff TSW2 to a Momo DFP, keeping > the TSW pedals as they're much better than the flimsy plastic ones that > come with the Momo. I couldn't be happier with the setup. I had > originially bought the DFP as a backup wheel so I could race while > converting my TSW over to USB using a plasma lite board, but I got > hooked on the excellent FF the DFP provides. > > Maybe you should consider that route, too. $80 on a DFP isn't too much, > and as the wheel is playstation compatible, you should have no trouble > selling it at a minor loss if you discover you don't like it. > > cheers, uwe > > -- > GPG Fingerprint: 2E 13 20 22 9A 3F 63 7F 67 6F E9 B1 A8 36 A4 61Larry wrote:
C'mon Larry, I've given you all the info previously to overcome this problem
;-)
It looks like this
http://img438.imageshack.us/my.php?image=200602050026ru.jpg
attach to the table like this
http://img521.imageshack.us/my.php?image=200602050031sr.jpg
and with the wheel attached
http://img438.imageshack.us/my.php?image=200602050048mu.jpg
Better than ANY clamp on any previous wheel of mine :-)
No excuses , DFP for the win
Deon
Quoted text (12 lines)
> I can't use a DFP. They blew the clamp design and if you have a > rounded-edge desk it won't stay in place. > > Why they shipped that without the center clamp is beyond my > comprehension. > I tried one. Took it back the same night. > > I clamped it to the desk tightly, turned around to move the box out > of the way, and it literally fell right off the desk onto the floor > all by itself. > -Larry >Quoted text (11 lines)
> I can't use a DFP. They blew the clamp design and if you have a > rounded-edge desk it won't stay in place. > Why they shipped that without the center clamp is beyond my > comprehension. > I tried one. Took it back the same night. > I clamped it to the desk tightly, turned around to move the box out > of the way, and it literally fell right off the desk onto the floor > all by itself. > -LarryI understand. I just don't have time for this crap.
I need things to work as expected out of the box.
My Momo is no issue. My MSFFW's were no issue.
They simply blew the design of the DFP.
Then again, the DFP was never meant for PC's so that may explain it.
-Larry
"�eon" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (26 lines)
> Larry wrote: >> I can't use a DFP. They blew the clamp design and if you have a >> rounded-edge desk it won't stay in place. >> >> Why they shipped that without the center clamp is beyond my >> comprehension. >> I tried one. Took it back the same night. >> >> I clamped it to the desk tightly, turned around to move the box out >> of the way, and it literally fell right off the desk onto the floor >> all by itself. >> -Larry >> > C'mon Larry, I've given you all the info previously to overcome this > problem ;-) > > It looks like this > http://img438.imageshack.us/my.php?image=200602050026ru.jpg > attach to the table like this > http://img521.imageshack.us/my.php?image=200602050031sr.jpg > and with the wheel attached > http://img438.imageshack.us/my.php?image=200602050048mu.jpg > > Better than ANY clamp on any previous wheel of mine :-) > No excuses , DFP for the win > Deonlol, just pulling that leg a bit..Even my Saitek R440 had a better clamp
than that .
One thing is for sure, that clamp of mine is future proof, and i dont have
to worry about wear and tear on the plastic wheel clamps.Plus it's easy to
move aside when not in use. Best thing I've ever talked my brother into
making :-)
Deon
Larry wrote:
Quoted text (40 lines)
> I understand. I just don't have time for this crap. > > I need things to work as expected out of the box. > > My Momo is no issue. My MSFFW's were no issue. > > They simply blew the design of the DFP. > > Then again, the DFP was never meant for PC's so that may explain it. > > -Larry > > "�eon" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:[email hidden]... >> Larry wrote: >>> I can't use a DFP. They blew the clamp design and if you have a >>> rounded-edge desk it won't stay in place. >>> >>> Why they shipped that without the center clamp is beyond my >>> comprehension. >>> I tried one. Took it back the same night. >>> >>> I clamped it to the desk tightly, turned around to move the box out >>> of the way, and it literally fell right off the desk onto the floor >>> all by itself. >>> -Larry >>> >> C'mon Larry, I've given you all the info previously to overcome this >> problem ;-) >> >> It looks like this >> http://img438.imageshack.us/my.php?image=200602050026ru.jpg >> attach to the table like this >> http://img521.imageshack.us/my.php?image=200602050031sr.jpg >> and with the wheel attached >> http://img438.imageshack.us/my.php?image=200602050048mu.jpg >> >> Better than ANY clamp on any previous wheel of mine :-) >> No excuses , DFP for the win >> Deonlol, just pulling that leg a bit..Even my Saitek R440 had a better clamp
than that .
One thing is for sure, that clamp of mine is future proof, and i dont have
to worry about wear and tear on the plastic wheel clamps.Plus it's easy to
move aside when not in use. Best thing I've ever talked my brother into
making :-)
Deon
