Overpriced ECCI wheel listing and FFB versus non-FFB
A link to an eBay listing for an ECCI wheel and pedals drew mockery about its price for a non-force-feedback wheel. The discussion became an exchange on whether force feedback is essential, with several long-time TSW and non-FFB users saying they did not miss it and others turning theirs down.
hardware: wheels/pedalsfor sale/trade
Automated summary.
"jwilson54" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:hnjjpq$rn1$[email hidden]...
> http://cgi.ebay.com/ECCI-Wheel-and-Pedals_W0QQitemZ110506931465QQcmdZViewItemQQptZLH_DefaultDomain_0?hash=item19bab9f509
You taketh the piss with that reserve. That wheel doesn't even have FFB!
David G Fisher's Left Testicle wrote:
Maybe you should check what they sell for ,before showing your ignorance
Quoted text (7 lines)
> > "jwilson54" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:hnjjpq$rn1$[email hidden]... >> http://cgi.ebay.com/ECCI-Wheel-and-Pedals_W0QQitemZ110506931465QQcmdZViewItemQQptZLH_DefaultDomain_0?hash=item19bab9f509 >> > > You taketh the piss with that reserve. That wheel doesn't even have FFB!
"jwilson54" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:hnjlu5$as7$[email hidden]...
You won't sell it at that price.
Quoted text (8 lines)
> David G Fisher's Left Testicle wrote: >> >> "jwilson54" <[email hidden]> wrote in message >> news:hnjjpq$rn1$[email hidden]... >>> http://cgi.ebay.com/ECCI-Wheel-and-Pedals_W0QQitemZ110506931465QQcmdZViewItemQQptZLH_DefaultDomain_0?hash=item19bab9f509 >> >> You taketh the piss with that reserve. That wheel doesn't even have FFB! > Maybe you should check what they sell for ,before showing your ignoranceDavid G Fisher's Left Testicle wrote:
Then it won't sell. He's not giving it away.
Quoted text (14 lines)
> > "jwilson54" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:hnjlu5$as7$[email hidden]... >> David G Fisher's Left Testicle wrote: >>> >>> "jwilson54" <[email hidden]> wrote in message >>> news:hnjjpq$rn1$[email hidden]... >>>> http://cgi.ebay.com/ECCI-Wheel-and-Pedals_W0QQitemZ110506931465QQcmdZViewItemQQptZLH_DefaultDomain_0?hash=item19bab9f509 >>>> >>> >>> You taketh the piss with that reserve. That wheel doesn't even have FFB! >> Maybe you should check what they sell for ,before showing your ignorance > > You won't sell it at that price.
"jwilson54" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:hnk5ae$99o$[email hidden]...
Who in their right mind would pay that sort of money for something that
doesn't even have FFB?
Quoted text (16 lines)
> David G Fisher's Left Testicle wrote: >> >> "jwilson54" <[email hidden]> wrote in message >> news:hnjlu5$as7$[email hidden]... >>> David G Fisher's Left Testicle wrote: >>>> >>>> "jwilson54" <[email hidden]> wrote in message >>>> news:hnjjpq$rn1$[email hidden]... >>>>> http://cgi.ebay.com/ECCI-Wheel-and-Pedals_W0QQitemZ110506931465QQcmdZViewItemQQptZLH_DefaultDomain_0?hash=item19bab9f509 >>>> >>>> You taketh the piss with that reserve. That wheel doesn't even have >>>> FFB! >>> Maybe you should check what they sell for ,before showing your ignorance >> >> You won't sell it at that price. > Then it won't sell. He's not giving it away. Yep. You could buy 3 G27s for that!
"David G Fisher's Left Testicle" <dfg.myass@aol> wrote in message
news:pPnnn.313183$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (23 lines)
> > "jwilson54" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:hnk5ae$99o$[email hidden]... >> David G Fisher's Left Testicle wrote: >>> >>> "jwilson54" <[email hidden]> wrote in message >>> news:hnjlu5$as7$[email hidden]... >>>> David G Fisher's Left Testicle wrote: >>>>> >>>>> "jwilson54" <[email hidden]> wrote in message >>>>> news:hnjjpq$rn1$[email hidden]... >>>>>> http://cgi.ebay.com/ECCI-Wheel-and-Pedals_W0QQitemZ110506931465QQcmdZViewItemQQptZLH_DefaultDomain_0?hash=item19bab9f509 >>>>> >>>>> You taketh the piss with that reserve. That wheel doesn't even have >>>>> FFB! >>>> Maybe you should check what they sell for ,before showing your >>>> ignorance >>> >>> You won't sell it at that price. >> Then it won't sell. He's not giving it away. > > Who in their right mind would pay that sort of money for something that > doesn't even have FFB?Are there still people out there who don't use FFB?
"Byron Forbes" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:4b9e0e08$[email hidden]...
Yep. You could buy 3 G27s for that!
"David G Fisher's Left Testicle" <dfg.myass@aol> wrote in message
news:pPnnn.313183$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (23 lines)
> > "jwilson54" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:hnk5ae$99o$[email hidden]... >> David G Fisher's Left Testicle wrote: >>> >>> "jwilson54" <[email hidden]> wrote in message >>> news:hnjlu5$as7$[email hidden]... >>>> David G Fisher's Left Testicle wrote: >>>>> >>>>> "jwilson54" <[email hidden]> wrote in message >>>>> news:hnjjpq$rn1$[email hidden]... >>>>>> http://cgi.ebay.com/ECCI-Wheel-and-Pedals_W0QQitemZ110506931465QQcmdZViewItemQQptZLH_DefaultDomain_0?hash=item19bab9f509 >>>>> >>>>> You taketh the piss with that reserve. That wheel doesn't even have >>>>> FFB! >>>> Maybe you should check what they sell for ,before showing your >>>> ignorance >>> >>> You won't sell it at that price. >> Then it won't sell. He's not giving it away. > > Who in their right mind would pay that sort of money for something that > doesn't even have FFB?David G Fisher's Left Testicle wrote:
> Are there still people out there who don't use FFB?
I have FFB but only use it in games that do FFB right. That means in
most I turn it off.
David G Fisher's Left Testicle wrote:
> Are there still people out there who don't use FFB?
That would be me. Never used it (Sidewinder non-FF wheel), nor felt the
need to.
Only time I've ever felt something like it was on the PS2's 'rumble'
gamepad with GT4....
Regards, R
(GPLRank: -40)
"Boris Badenov" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:hnoqfh$tct$[email hidden]...
> David G Fisher's Left Testicle wrote:
>> Are there still people out there who don't use FFB?
>
> I have FFB but only use it in games that do FFB right. That means in most
> I turn it off.
The only sims worth playing are the ones that have good FFB.
"Ruud Dingemans" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:33040$4b9feb55$5418583d$[email hidden]...
So you've never even tried it?
Quoted text (10 lines)
> David G Fisher's Left Testicle wrote: >> Are there still people out there who don't use FFB? > > That would be me. Never used it (Sidewinder non-FF wheel), nor felt the > need to. > Only time I've ever felt something like it was on the PS2's 'rumble' > gamepad with GT4.... > > Regards, R > (GPLRank: -40)David G Fisher's Left Testicle wrote:
I tried FFB,with the red momo.Thought I couldn,t live without it,but
bought a TSW2 anyway. I wouldn't go back to the plastic wheels again.
Quoted text (15 lines)
> > "Ruud Dingemans" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:33040$4b9feb55$5418583d$[email hidden]... >> David G Fisher's Left Testicle wrote: >>> Are there still people out there who don't use FFB? >> >> That would be me. Never used it (Sidewinder non-FF wheel), nor felt >> the need to. >> Only time I've ever felt something like it was on the PS2's 'rumble' >> gamepad with GT4.... >> >> Regards, R >> (GPLRank: -40) > > So you've never even tried it?
"jwilson54" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:hnqm24$pcs$[email hidden]...
The working parts in the red Momo are all metal. The TSW2 uses a bit of
bungee cord from what I remember.
Quoted text (18 lines)
> David G Fisher's Left Testicle wrote: >> >> "Ruud Dingemans" <[email hidden]> wrote in message >> news:33040$4b9feb55$5418583d$[email hidden]... >>> David G Fisher's Left Testicle wrote: >>>> Are there still people out there who don't use FFB? >>> >>> That would be me. Never used it (Sidewinder non-FF wheel), nor felt the >>> need to. >>> Only time I've ever felt something like it was on the PS2's 'rumble' >>> gamepad with GT4.... >>> >>> Regards, R >>> (GPLRank: -40) >> >> So you've never even tried it? > I tried FFB,with the red momo.Thought I couldn,t live without it,but > bought a TSW2 anyway. I wouldn't go back to the plastic wheels again.On Wed, 17 Mar 2010 15:42:55 -0000, David G Fisher's Left Testicle wrote:
> The working parts in the red Momo are all metal. The TSW2 uses a bit of
> bungee cord from what I remember.
>
Na, that would have been the Thrustmaster wheels, not the TSW ones. I
owned a TSW2 stock for a long time too and despised those plasticky ff
wheels, I only gave up on it when I couldn't manage to convert the
gameport model to a decent USB connected one (even tried the Beta
Innovations board, but the resulting resolution was just too low for
my tastes).
The g25 / 27 isn't half bad for half the price, though, and I couldn't
live without ff these days.
I still use the tsw pedals for rudder control in flightsims. I know
it's overkill, but they're nice and sturdy and will probably last
until the heat death of the universe from their feel.
uwe
"David G Fisher's Left Testicle" <dfg.myass@aol> wrote in
news:FUrnn.397275$[email hidden]:
> Are there still people out there who don't use FFB?
> Never. I have used an old thrustmater on NFS:PU, but that was the last
time. It add's something, but not g forces or any illusion thereof, so I
don't bother.
David G Fisher's Left Testicle wrote:
Did once, on a Sidewinder FF wheel, but found it kind of tiring to
wrestle the wheel the whole time. I like me wheels light and responsive.
Not having dual axis pedals was a much bigger handicap back then. (And
although rumbling over the kerbs seemed ok, found the FF not
particularly immersive. Maybe if I'd also integrated a Buttkicker or
somesuch ;) Anyway, never really felt the need to have it. Nice extra,
but for me that's about it. As long as I can *hear* (and to some extent,
see) I'm going over the kerbs or the like, I don't particularly mind.
Quoted text (8 lines)
>>> Are there still people out there who don't use FFB? >> >> That would be me. Never used it (Sidewinder non-FF wheel), nor felt >> the need to. >> Regards, R >> (GPLRank: -40) > > So you've never even tried it? [email hidden] (Ruud Dingemans) wrote:
> Anyway, never really felt the need to have it. Nice extra,
> but for me that's about it.
When I first started iRacing I was using my old Red Momo. The FFB on that felt
great and really added to the experience. But since I upgraded to a G25, although
the wheel itself and the pedals are excellent, I've never felt happy with the FFB.
So I have it dialled back.
At the right time and place (eg losing traction at the crest of a hill) the FFB
*really* adds to the experience, and it can be a big help feeling the car starting
to get away from you. But overall I think racing in front of a screen relies far
more on visual and aural clues than the potentially laggy FFB. It's part of the
window dressing rather than essential.
However it's great window dressing when it works well and at risk of reminding
everyone what a low-grade sim racing wannabe I am, in NFS:Shift I love the FFB on
my G25, and find it really satisfying.
Andrew McP
I have the FFB turned down on my G25 also. Best thing I have done was
adapt the wheel from my race car to bolt onto the G25 base in place of
the mini wheel it comes with.
Quoted text (22 lines)
>On Fri, 19 Mar 2010 08:38 +0000 (GMT Standard Time), [email hidden] (Andrew MacPherson) wrote: > [email hidden] (Ruud Dingemans) wrote: > >> Anyway, never really felt the need to have it. Nice extra, >> but for me that's about it. > >When I first started iRacing I was using my old Red Momo. The FFB on that felt >great and really added to the experience. But since I upgraded to a G25, although >the wheel itself and the pedals are excellent, I've never felt happy with the FFB. >So I have it dialled back. > >At the right time and place (eg losing traction at the crest of a hill) the FFB >*really* adds to the experience, and it can be a big help feeling the car starting >to get away from you. But overall I think racing in front of a screen relies far >more on visual and aural clues than the potentially laggy FFB. It's part of the >window dressing rather than essential. > >However it's great window dressing when it works well and at risk of reminding >everyone what a low-grade sim racing wannabe I am, in NFS:Shift I love the FFB on >my G25, and find it really satisfying. > >Andrew McPOn Mar 18, 4:45 am, Uwe <[email hidden]> wrote:
I've had the same TSW for near on ten years now, maybe more. I had it
converted to USB last year and I don't miss FFB one bit (I've never
used it). The wheel is as sturdy as the day I bought it and shows no
signs of the important bits wearing out. I've got close to $600 in it
now between the original purchase and the USB upgrade, but spread out
over time, I'd have probably bought at least three lesser wheels by
now, so it's money even in my eyes.


































