Does the T2 formula set-up need one or two joystick ports.
I am very keen for an answer. Thanks to anybody who can
help.
Andrew Easter
Thrustmaster T2 shared brake/throttle axis explained
A question about whether the Formula T2 needs one or two joystick ports led to a discussion of its pedals. Rick Genter of Papyrus confirmed that on the T2 the brake and throttle share a single axis, with each taking half the range, so the two cannot really be applied at once. Owners argued about whether left-foot braking still worked. One owner found the wheel cheap-feeling, and Walt Otten pointed readers to his guide to building a homemade wheel, pedals and motion chair.
With Rick Genter (Papyrus)
Automated summary.
says...
It runs into one joystick port. I've been very happy with mine.
Bill aka BillyJoe (on Hawaii)
--------------------------------------------------------------
Centrimedia web development
http://www.centrimedia.com/
--------------------------------------------------------------
I just got a T2 and am seriously considering taking it back. It just has
such a cheap feel to it. I have a question, does any of the "better" (7
or 8 and up) drivers on Hawaii use it? I figure it'll take ALOT of
getting used to at the very least.
Phil
says...
It only requires one port. The wheel plugs into the pedals, which in turn
plug into the port. I highly suggest a true game port though; using one on
your sound card can produce flaky results from game to game.
-Aaron Taylor
?
?>It runs into one joystick port. I've been very happy with mine.
?>
?>Bill aka BillyJoe (on Hawaii)
?>
?>
?
?I just got a T2 and am seriously considering taking it back. It just has
?such a cheap feel to it. I have a question, does any of the "better" (7
?or 8 and up) drivers on Hawaii use it? I figure it'll take ALOT of
?getting used to at the very least.
Are you seriously talking about the same T2 everyone else is?
Granted, it's not made out of Titanium, but for $100, what on earth
did you expect?? I find that it's extremely well made for the money,
and it's *leagues* ahead of using my $70 joystick. What were you
using before that you could be so disappointed with a new T2??
--Evan
Quoted text (7 lines)
> says... > >Does the T2 formula set-up need one or two joystick ports. > >I am very keen for an answer. Thanks to anybody who can > >help. > It runs into one joystick port. I've been very happy with mine.>I don't understand this - how can you use simultaneous brake and
>throttle with only one analogue channel (given that the other is
>used for steering)?
On the T2, the brake and throttle are the same axis (the brake gets one
half of the range, and the throttle gets the other half).
Rick Genter
Technical Lead, IndyCar Racing II
Sierra On-Line, Inc.
Quoted text (17 lines)
> > says... > > >Does the T2 formula set-up need one or two joystick ports. > > >I am very keen for an answer. Thanks to anybody who can > > >help. > > It runs into one joystick port. I've been very happy with mine. > I don't understand this - how can you use simultaneous brake and > throttle with only one analogue channel (given that the other is > used for steering)? > On my CH pedal/yoke combo (which is admittedly a compromise to my > driving/flying interests) I use X1 for steering and X2, Y2 for > brake and throttle, requiring a two port interface. > Regards, > James.writes:
Evan,
For $100 I expected it to beat out my $5 kraft joystick on the first
night. (I was mistakenly, obviously) I'll practice ALOT more with it
before I comment again. The thing moved off it's clamps more than once
and *that* was pretty cruddy. I feel like it'll break after about a
hundred hours of use. Does anyone know if the TSW wheel has buttons on
the steering wheel itself or is that just the ECC system?
Phil
Quoted text (10 lines)
> >I don't understand this - how can you use simultaneous brake and > >throttle with only one analogue channel (given that the other is > >used for steering)? > On the T2, the brake and throttle are the same axis (the brake gets one > half of the range, and the throttle gets the other half). > Rick Genter > Technical Lead, IndyCar Racing II > Sierra On-Line, Inc.>>I don't understand this - how can you use simultaneous brake and
>>throttle with only one analogue channel (given that the other is
>>used for steering)?
>On the T2, the brake and throttle are the same axis (the brake gets one
>half of the range, and the throttle gets the other half).
Doesn't that mean one >can't< use the brake while on the throttle with
the T2? If so, ew.
--
http://members.cruzio.com/~keeper/ Funny Looking Little Kitty, 1982-1996
Quoted text (21 lines)
>Subject: Re: Formula T2 Question >Date: Wed, 15 May 1996 15:43:43 GMT >> >I don't understand this - how can you use simultaneous brake and >> >throttle with only one analogue channel (given that the other is >> >used for steering)? >> On the T2, the brake and throttle are the same axis (the brake gets one >> half of the range, and the throttle gets the other half). >> Rick Genter >> Technical Lead, IndyCar Racing II >> Sierra On-Line, Inc. >So, it's impossible to brake and accelerate at the same time? >Ricardo OberpaurQuoted text (20 lines)
> ?Niemeyer) writes: > ? > ?>It runs into one joystick port. I've been very happy with mine. > ?> > ?>Bill aka BillyJoe (on Hawaii) > ?> > ?> > ? > ?I just got a T2 and am seriously considering taking it back. It just has > ?such a cheap feel to it. I have a question, does any of the "better" (7 > ?or 8 and up) drivers on Hawaii use it? I figure it'll take ALOT of > ?getting used to at the very least. > Are you seriously talking about the same T2 everyone else is? > Granted, it's not made out of Titanium, but for $100, what on earth > did you expect?? I find that it's extremely well made for the money, > and it's *leagues* ahead of using my $70 joystick. What were you > using before that you could be so disappointed with a new T2?? > --EvanThe TSW has buttons for up and downshift on the wheel, in addition to a
gear shift. Either can be used.
Cheers!
John
_________________________________
__ _____| |_____ __
_________| |__| :| John Wallace | |__| |_________
\ :| |::| :| Team WW Racing TSW | |::| | /
> :| |::| :|_________________________________| |::| | < / :|__|::|____:/ Sim Racing News \.____|::|__| \
/_______:/ \::/ http://www.dcn.ed.ac.uk/pulse/index.htm \::/ \._______\
Quoted text (18 lines)
> writes: > >Are you seriously talking about the same T2 everyone else is? > >Granted, it's not made out of Titanium, but for $100, what on earth > >did you expect?? I find that it's extremely well made for the money, > >and it's *leagues* ahead of using my $70 joystick. What were you > >using before that you could be so disappointed with a new T2?? > Evan, > For $100 I expected it to beat out my $5 kraft joystick on the first > night. (I was mistakenly, obviously) I'll practice ALOT more with it > before I comment again. The thing moved off it's clamps more than once > and *that* was pretty cruddy. I feel like it'll break after about a > hundred hours of use. Does anyone know if the TSW wheel has buttons on > the steering wheel itself or is that just the ECC system? > Phil(Evan)
>> writes:
>> >Are you seriously talking about the same T2 everyone else is?
>> >Granted, it's not made out of Titanium, but for $100, what on earth
>> >did you expect?? I find that it's extremely well made for the money,
it
>> before I comment again. The thing moved off it's clamps more than once
>> and *that* was pretty cruddy. I feel like it'll break after about a
>> hundred hours of use. Does anyone know if the TSW wheel has buttons on
that's the steering wheel I saw,
told me that, like with the T2, you can't
as I know, ECC is the only one that
about the buttons on the steering wheel).
To throw my two cents worth in (which is about a nickel over priced), I
also race on a T2. Due to limitations with the desk my computer sits
on, I was not able to use the clamp system that comes with the wheel.
I modified it to mount on a piece of shelving material about 14' x 14'.
I then took the plastic clamps that come with the wheel, drilled and
bolted them to the shelf so that the end of the wheel unit just sticks
over the edge of the board. I then mount the wheel unit to the board
via the screws that come with the wheel, through the plastic clamps.
My computer desk has a slide out keyboard tray. I C-clamp the end of
the board to the back of the tray. This has provided a very stable
platform for the wheel unit, which coinsidently makes it about the same
height and position as the wheel in the Austin Healey 3000 we vintage
race (ie familiar and comfortable).
The room where I have my computer has a vinyl floor, and sliding has
been minimal. However, a piece or two of duct tape takes care of and
slide problem, probably work on carpet too. The pedal position is not
optimal, and taking the unit apart, does not look like the brake pedal
could be moved to the open slot on the left side. It is my assumption
that the base is probably used for a flight flap/rudder set as well.
Thin soled shoes, like driving shoes work well for me, Nike's do not.
Now if they would just replicate along with the feel of the car, the
feel of a five point harness tugging at you on hard deceleration or
acceleration, the wind rush at 150 mph... I ramble on.
Jerry
Quoted text (7 lines)
>> >and it's *leagues* ahead of using my $70 joystick. What were you >> >using before that you could be so disappointed with a new T2?? >> Evan, >> For $100 I expected it to beat out my $5 kraft joystick on the first >> night. (I was mistakenly, obviously) I'll practice ALOT more withQuoted text (7 lines)
>> the steering wheel itself or is that just the ECC system? >> Phil >Phil, >As for your question, the TSW has buttons on the steernig wheel (OK,> > On the T2, the brake and throttle are the same axis (the brake gets one
> > half of the range, and the throttle gets the other half).
> So, it's impossible to brake and accelerate at the same time?
> Ricardo Oberpaur
No, not that I've seen. I've used both methods and it definitely seems
to allow acceleration and braking at the same time. I just gently press
on the brake with my left foot while I let off the gas going into the
turn. Then, I gently apply gas and let off brake as I come out of the
turn. It is smooth like that.
When I get off of the gas totally and press on the brake with my right foot,
It slows much more and the weight transfer has a more *** effect on
the car sometimes. I much prefer to keep one foot on the gas and one on
the brake. I also see the RPMs increasing as I give gas with the brake on,
but my speed doesn't go up. So in short: it seems like gas and brake can
be applied at the same time with the T2.
Rob Ryder
Quoted text (55 lines)
>>> Evan, >>> For $100 I expected it to beat out my $5 kraft joystick on the first >>> night. (I was mistakenly, obviously) I'll practice ALOT more with >it >>> before I comment again. The thing moved off it's clamps more than >once >>> and *that* was pretty cruddy. I feel like it'll break after about a >>> hundred hours of use. Does anyone know if the TSW wheel has >buttons on >>> the steering wheel itself or is that just the ECC system? >>> Phil >>Phil, >>As for your question, the TSW has buttons on the steernig wheel (OK, >that's the steering wheel I saw, >>maybe it was modified). >>I'm considering buying an ECC. I asked about the TSW, but somebody >told me that, like with the T2, you can't >>apply brakes and throttle at the same time (that's a shame!). As far >as I know, ECC is the only one that >>supports this feature, but there is some problem with NFS (something >about the buttons on the steering wheel). >>Since I only use F1GP, I'll go for the ECC. >>Ricardo >To throw my two cents worth in (which is about a nickel over priced), I >also race on a T2. Due to limitations with the desk my computer sits >on, I was not able to use the clamp system that comes with the wheel. >I modified it to mount on a piece of shelving material about 14' x 14'. >I then took the plastic clamps that come with the wheel, drilled and >bolted them to the shelf so that the end of the wheel unit just sticks >over the edge of the board. I then mount the wheel unit to the board >via the screws that come with the wheel, through the plastic clamps. >My computer desk has a slide out keyboard tray. I C-clamp the end of >the board to the back of the tray. This has provided a very stable >platform for the wheel unit, which coinsidently makes it about the same >height and position as the wheel in the Austin Healey 3000 we vintage >race (ie familiar and comfortable). >The room where I have my computer has a vinyl floor, and sliding has >been minimal. However, a piece or two of duct tape takes care of and >slide problem, probably work on carpet too. The pedal position is not >optimal, and taking the unit apart, does not look like the brake pedal >could be moved to the open slot on the left side. It is my assumption >that the base is probably used for a flight flap/rudder set as well. >Thin soled shoes, like driving shoes work well for me, Nike's do not. >Now if they would just replicate along with the feel of the car, the >feel of a five point harness tugging at you on hard deceleration or >acceleration, the wind rush at 150 mph... I ramble on. >Jerry[snip - lets hope I still get the attribs right]
I'm sorry, I can't see how that can be possible. If the brake and gas use the
same axis, then there can only be one value generated for any given combination
of pedal positions. There's no way I can see that you could apply full brake and
full gas at the same time.
My guess is that you are seeing either one pedal over-riding the other one, or a
difference due to changes in your driving style when you use pedal combinations.
Regards,
James.
James is correct. If you look at the values that change with a joystick diagnostic
program..... A T2 is a single pot that you can alter. If you press the "gas" down 100
value points, and then press the brake down 50 value points, it is the same as just
pushing the gas down 50.
On the other hand, the CH flight pedals have a switch that will allow it to be a single
axis device our a dual axis device.... With it, you can have any value of accelration
mixed with any value of brake. The other difference is that the T2 can be used as Axis
2 on Joystick 1 for cards that only support one joystick, where the CH pedals are
designed to be Joystick 2
I don't know how NASCAR or INDYCAR deal with this - if they do at all. Yes, Rick
Genter, this is your cue :-)
For those of us who have driven two-footed style in a real racing situation, it may be
that we just imagine the Nascar sim behaving differently because we 'expect' it to.
The mind is a mysterious thing.
Much like driving with a joystick makes it feel like a game, but using a wheel and
pedals makes you get "lost in it". Even if it takes some getting used to and your times
are reduced, you don't want to go back to the "game" feel.
Mike Dr2
>I don't know how NASCAR or INDYCAR deal with this - if they do at all. Yes,
>Rick
>Genter, this is your cue :-)
Oh, uh, ahem. :-) NASCAR and IndyCar II allow "half" of an axis to be
acceleration, braking or reverse. (The halfway point is the value read
when the joystick/pedals are released, not the average of the low and high
values.)
Rick Genter
Technical Lead, IndyCar Racing II
Sierra On-Line, Inc.
I've used the brake and gas simultaneously in Need For Speed and it works....
> I'm sorry, I can't see how that can be possible. If the brake and gas use the
> same axis, then there can only be one value generated for any given combination
> of pedal positions. There's no way I can see that you could apply full brake and
> full gas at the same time.
I never apply full gas and full brake. It's just that the brake depressed
half way has a more distinct and *** braking effect on the car. But when
I depress the brake half way and keep up the gas, say at 3/4, it seems to brake
more easily and transition more smoothly on the gas.
Perhaps some of both. Actually, the RPMs don't change as the gas pedal is smashed
(wish they did), just the speed. But there is a difference when they are both used
together. Perhaps the input is varied very very quickly like: left right left right
left right very fast, don't know enough about it to comment. That is just pure
speculation.
Rob Ryder
--
There's nothing you can do that can't be done
Nothing you can sing that can't be sung
John Lennon (All You Need Is Love 1967)


































